Peter C.
8/15/2025
Service is great and food up scale from what it was Inside is fun and comfortable Highly recommended
Rustic Cafe
$$
Closed
(239)
Photos
516 Boston Post Rd
East Lyme, CT 06333
The Rustic originally opened as a large restaurant, bar and dance hall. It was known to have the likes of Frank Sinatra stop by for an evening out. After a devastating fire, it was rebuilt in 1969 to its present, cozy size. Eccentric locals and summer tourists alike now enjoy local craft beer and creative cocktails in an open wood-beam atmosphere under the original iconic sign.
Reviews
4.0(239)
Richard M.
1/17/2026
Food was delicious! However a little feedback. Restaurant can't really accommodate a group of 5 or more. Steak toast(my dish) was delicious as well BUT I would advise diners that the portion is...
Sheryl J.
11/4/2025
Gave this unique little treasure a shot for burgers and was not disappointed! The funky atmosphere is like no other, and the service was warm, friendly, and efficient. I asked to sub a salad for...
Kate J.
9/6/2025
Service was friendly and attentive. Casual food. The best sticky toffee pudding dessert!
Jan B.
11/30/2023
My friend and I had a blast at Rustic Cafe . I would love to come back and try some other items on their menu . We tried the stuffed clams .. Delicious!! Such a fun place !!!
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2026. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.