Sarah S.
4/14/2023
They have THE BEST key lime pie. We were referred by our hosts here & must pass on this insider info! The store brand is the one to buy!! Also note but they have some fantastic art supplies and...
Trading Post Grocery Store
$
Open
(58)
Photos
81868 Overseas Hwy
Islamorada, FL 33036
The Trading Post is always open, and proud to serve you 24 hours a day, 7 days a week, 365 days a year! Family owned and operated since 1966, The Trading Post Grocery Store is your one stop shop. Choose from our selection of the finest meats, fresh seasonal produce, extensive beer and wine inventory and full service deli. Don't forget our fried chicken and world famous key lime pie! Our friendly staff is always on hand to help you find just what you're looking for.
Also at this address
Reviews
4.0(58)
Denise S.
11/20/2025
Loved this store. Wished we knew about it before going to Publix for snacks. Would have preferred supporting a long term local establishment. We found it from our Florida Keys food tour since...
Johnny M.
12/27/2025
Very expensive! 26$ for a 12 pack of Modelo! When I asked the old woman for a price on another brand of beer she got upset and said "i DONT KNOW I JUST WORK HERE! "
Heidi P.
5/6/2025
They have the best key lime ice cream! If you like key lime pie, you will love this. Nice staff.
Sky T.
3/22/2021
First caught sight of this on Google Maps as 'Key Lime Pie Lady,' but it's actually a product that is sold at this trading post. There is also a coffee shop, burrito shop, boutiques in the same...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2026. All rights reserved.