Chris S.
8/21/2025
Pepperoni's Tavern has been holding it down in Alpharetta since 1997, which is longer than some of the "one-star Yelpers" have probably been out of their parents' basements. I come here every...
Pepperoni's Tavern
$$
Closed
(157)
Photos
4190 Old Milton Pkwy Ste 2A
Alpharetta, GA 30005
The Pepperoni's brand was born in Duluth, Georgia in 1997. Phil's grandparents were in the hospitality business - Phil's Grandfather owned a "saloon" in Northern Kentucky called "Charlie's". His establishment was renowned in it's time. As frequently happens, his parents chose not to continue in the family business. The passion returned a generation later. Phil worked in foodservice in his teens and had an awakening while working for the C.A. Muer Corporation. He became a manager for the well known Detroit seafood restaurateur. During his time there, he was privileged to work for Corporate Chef and native Italian Larry Pagliari. Chef Larry was notorious for his obsession for "Quality Meals". This statement remains in the Pepperoni's mission and logo to this day.
Also at this address
Reviews
3.5157 reviews
Priscilla B.
12/24/2025
Pepperonis Tavern is and always will be an amazing hidden gem in the heart of Johns creek. You will ALWAYS have incredible pizza here. I HIGHLY recommend the lemonyaki wings paired with a cold brew!
Mike K.
12/28/2025
This is a Steeler bar. It's been around in Alpharetta for over 25 years. Pizza is solid and the food overall is very good. The meatball appetizers are huge, moist and excellent. Service is good...
Dave A.
8/4/2025
Our neighborhood gem! We love the wait staff, owner Phil and the food. The Greek Salad, Nachos and pizza are our favorites! We love to stop in whenever there is a craving for pizza, a beer and a...
Dave B.
3/15/2024
Being in my old neighborhood I had to stop in for a bite after some range shooting with the guys. One of my first reviews when I was just starting out as a Yelper. lol Not much has changed. A...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2026. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.