Mary Jo McGuire's

Closed
yelp logo

(10)

Photos

2251 N Lincoln Ave
Chicago, IL 60614

Reviews

yelp logo
4.010 reviews
Jimmy O.
11/29/2025

really really good pizza and great vibes. dare I say it's better than the original Butch McGuire's? blasphemy, I know. I have been a regular at Butches for years it is so refreshing to see a bar...

Photo of Darcy G.
Darcy G.
10/26/2025

Came here on a late Sunday afternoon. Lots of seating at the bar, good service. Similar ambiance to butch mcguires obviously. (I wonder if they will do Christmas lights!) they also have touch...

Photo of Josh A.
Josh A.
11/1/2025

Bar has so much potential. I went on opening weekend so probs will be awesome soon. Lots of space and wasn't so packed that I felt claustrophobic. A couple of notes about some areas of...

Photo of Joan N.
Joan N.
12/25/2025

Definitely the little‑sister spot--less nostalgic, but still festive, and yes, there's a train. The giardiniera pizza packs a serious punch, and bonus points for being open on Christmas Day.

Photo of Elaine L.
Elaine L.
12/1/2025

Maybe we stopped by on the wrong day, but we were a little disappointed. The holiday decorations were beautiful which is what attracted us to this spot as we were on our way to king of cups. We...

Own this business?
See a problem?

You might also like

United StatesIllinoisChicagoMary Jo McGuire's

Partial Data by Foursquare.