Caplinger's Fresh Catch

$$
Closed
yelp logo

(936)

Call
Website

Photos

7460 N Shadeland Ave Ste 400
Indianapolis, IN 46250
+1 (317) 288-7263
https://caplingersfreshcatch.com
We are a family friendly atmosphere. Limited seating, outdoor seating weather permitting. Very affordable fish and seafood fare. From sandwiches to po/boys,homemade sides,sauces and desserts. Fresh baked buns and rolls for every sandwich. Voted #1 Restaurant in The State of Indiana three different times. Come see what everyone is talking about. Caplinger's Fresh Catch open Tuesday-Saturday. We also have a full, gourmet Fish Market with fresh fish being delivered daily. Call for special orders

Also at this address

Find related places

Restaurants

Reviews

yelp logo
4.5936 reviews
Photo of Brenda J.
Brenda J.
8/28/2025

Today I felt like a treat, so I ordered the lobster roll and a side of hush puppies! Yum YUm and YUM! Everything about how they season the lobster roll appeals to me. The hush puppies are cooked...

Read more on Yelp
Photo of Laura S.
Laura S.
11/9/2025

All the food is bursting with flavor. I love fried okra. The only comment is I like the coating on the outside a little thicker. I dunked my okra in the Chipotle aoli sauce and that was a treat....

Read more on Yelp
Photo of Jazmine D.
Jazmine D.
10/16/2025

Food, service, and atmosphere is authentic and welcoming. Food is always fresh a little pricey especially in this economy but if you not broke like me go for it! Customer service needs work but...

Read more on Yelp
Photo of Angie D.
Angie D.
12/22/2025

We love Caplinger's!! Food is amazing and always consistent. The hush puppies? So good.

Read more on Yelp
Stacy F.
1/3/2026

Bought sea scallops for a special occasion, and the quality exceeded expectations. Thank you!

Read more on Yelp
Own this business?
See a problem?

You might also like

American restaurant, Fish and seafood markets, Eating places

Jordan Fish Chicken Gyros

Jordan Fish Chicken Gyros is a popular eatery in Indianapolis, IN, specializing in a diverse menu that features a variety of chicken wings, fish dishes, and Chicago-style sandwiches. Customers can enjoy options ranging from crispy chicken tenders and flavorful gyros to hearty salads and kid-friendly meals. In addition to their main offerings, the restaurant provides a selection of sides, desserts, and beverages, making it a convenient choice for carryout orders. With a focus on quality and customer satisfaction, Jordan Fish Chicken Gyros has garnered a loyal following among local diners. Generated from the website
Taste This Fish
Fish markets, Eating places

Taste This Fish

35
•
$$$
"I am a whole catfish snob and this place passed my tests! Even their French fries are tasty!!! Carry out only! Staff friendly and helpful! Definitely will be back!"
photo of Denise H.
Juicy Seafood Indy
Eating places, Fish and seafood markets

Juicy Seafood Indy

317
•
$$
"First time trying this place in indianapolis.. Ajacia was the best 10/10 recommend and I will come again. She recommended what to get, slice level, and excellent customer service as it being our..."
United States›Indiana›Indianapolis›Caplinger's Fresh Catch

Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2026. All rights reserved.

Partial Data by Foursquare.