Michelle C.
10/14/2025
The ambiance is a 10. The staff, a 10. If you are hungry it's a no but if you are into tasting different flavors then it's a definite yes! It's a fun spot to try.
PostBoy
Closed
(103)
Photos
207 N Whittaker St
New Buffalo, MI 49117
PostBoy in New Buffalo, MI, pays homage to a piece of maritime history with its name and location on Whittaker Street. The restaurant is situated where Captain Whittaker's schooner, Post Boy, wrecked in 1834 after serving as a USPS mail ship on the Great Lakes. Inspired by the beauty of New Buffalo, Captain Whittaker and his crew decided to settle in the area, giving rise to the town's name and the adventurous spirit that PostBoy embraces today.
Located in downtown New Buffalo, PostBoy offers a dining experience that reflects the historic connection to the area and the adventurous legacy of Captain Whittaker and his crew. The restaurant invites guests to embark on their own culinary journey, celebrating the rich history of the Great Lakes region while looking forward to new adventures. With a menu that promises a memorable experience, PostBoy invites diners to savor the flavors of the past and present in a setting that captures the essence of exploration and discovery.
Generated from the website content
Also at this address
Reviews
4.5103 reviews
Chris M.
10/26/2025
Really unique food! I can't even describe the French onion dip which was amazing! They have been in business for a year. They change their menu seasonally. Every staff member was...
Jeff L.
10/18/2025
Fun new eclectic eating experience. In New Buffalo. If you are a foodie, this is the place for you. Smash burger like a real Big Mac!! Wings terrific and carrots. Fun and creative atmosphere....
Maddi V.
8/30/2025
What a cute spot in downtown New Buffalo! We went to celebrate a birthday and enjoyed the robust selection of tapas to try a lot of different menu items. There are some large plates if your party...
Teresa L.
8/10/2025
Decided to stop in for a bite and it was new for us both. Cute little diner scene. Reminded me of a beachy Peach Pit. We were seated right away. We could have sat outside but it's a 90°+ day....
See a problem?