Silvie C.
1/11/2026
Surprisingly phenomenal slice in EV. I wish this place had more reviews and ergo more visibility. David L is right, if this spot were in an area with more foot traffic, it would be much busier....
Andrea's Pizza
Closed
(11)
Photos
50 2nd Ave
New York, NY 10003
Andrea's Pizza brings authentic, old-school New York-style slices to the heart of the East Village. Founded by veteran pizzaiolo Andrea Kenuti, formerly of Scarrs Pizza and L'Industrie, the pizzeria opened its doors at 50 2nd Ave in July 2025. Every thin-crusted pie is hand-tossed, lightly charred, and topped with perfectly balanced tomato sauce and melty, salty cheese, earning rave reviews from local tastemakers. With cozy indoor booths, outdoor tables, and delivery rolling out soon, Andrea's blends nostalgic flavor with a modern, neighborhood vibe. Stop in noon to midnight daily (extended weekend hours) for the kind of slice that keeps East Villagers and visitors coming back for more.
Also at this address
Reviews
5.0(11)
Brionna R.
12/13/2025
Amazing pizza and even better service! The beef pepperoni pizza is amazing and you must try the grandmas pizza!
david l.
12/4/2025
Andrea's puts put a classic NYC Slice. Thin and well cooked. One bite 8.2. The location is on a quite part of 2nd Ave. If they were in a busier spot they would be very busy.
Hannah H.
7/8/2025
Andrea's Pizza is a cute spot to pickup a slice or a whole pie - note that they are currently pickup only, but a delivery option will be offered soon! We did a pickup of: +a Classic Cheese slice...
Make J.
10/17/2025
This place is some of the best pizza I have ever had in NYC. HIGHLY RECOMMEND. an absolute must.
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Foursquare.